Formulating a Case Response on the SOA and UFE

Please don’t be fooled by the SOA/UFE Solutions provided. You’re not expected or required to present your responses in such beautiful prose. The Sample Responses provided are a lot closer to the real deal in terms of format/style but they, too, are very high quality which most candidates will never reach. It’s important to understand that your response will be more direct and point-form style without going to the extreme of that.

If you’ve done a fantastic outline, the way your formulate your response should be very easy and should make it easy for the marker to follow.

Always title your report/response

Your goal is to make your responses very easy to follow and read for the marker. If they can’t find what they’re looking for, they may not start looking for it. Don’t tempt fate. Always title your report (of which you may have many if the simulation demands it).

Report To / Audit Planning Memo / Memo To : and give a name of the partner, company, etc.

Use clear headings and subheadings in a logical way

I was always a fan of bolding and indenting.

Required #1 (Heading)

  • Issue #1a
    • Analysis
    • Analysis
  • Issue #1b
    • Analysis

Required #2 (Heading)

  • Issue #2a
    • Analysis
    • Analysis
    • Analysis

Conclusion/Recommendation: (if warranted)

  • Based on x, y and z the appropriate treatment/etc. is z.

And so forth as necessary. Of course you can make some modification here but your responses should have a similar flow.

Quants should be done separately (unless very short) in the spreadsheet software and then only referenced to in the analysis. More to come here.

Here’s an example of this format:

Identification of Accounting Issues at XYZ Corp.

  • New Machine in Use
    • Given the circumstances and IFRS requirements, the new machine will need to be tested for signs of impairment on a regular basis. Under IFRS the method to test for impairment is to discount the future cashflows that the machine will generate and compare to the current balance sheet value. If the discounted cash flows are less than the current value, the machine must be written down (impaired) to the present value of the discounted cash flows.
    • In this case the PV (at 7% discount rate) is $1.1M x 15 Year Life Discounted at 7% and compared to the book value of $1.5M. This will not be impaired this year.
  • Next Issue
    • Analysis on that issue.

(I just pulled this out of an old case so pay attention to style, not content!)

This is not a rule. The point here is that it’s important to be clear in your flow and discussion going through. Simulation responses that are all over the place and difficult to follow not only annoys markers but makes it very difficult in some cases to understand your arguments and discussion. I find organizing the response in ways such as these helps to clarify it both for yourself and for the marker.

 

What are some of the other tips/suggestions past or present writers have when formulating a response?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Commenting Guidelines

I love open conversations. Casual is fine, professional is fine, but this is a community so anything abusive, demeaning or annoying will be removed at my discretion. Below is a guide to help keep you on the straight and narrow.

  1. 1. Use a name or alias. I understand wanting to keep your name personal, so make something clever up and stick to it. We can't tell each other apart if everybody is "Anon".
  2. 2. Remember the point. This is a community to discuss, debate and assist each other to pass the CFE or discuss other CPA things. Let's act like we're all the intelligent professionals that we are supposed to be.
  3. 3. No personal attacks. It's okay to disagree with opinions or advice but argue the point, not the person.
  4. 4. Don't be obnoxious. You should be proud if you are the next honour roll writer or work for a prestigious firm but don't be obnoxious by using it to feel better than others.

*

Other Great Reads

Get the Latest CFE News

Get the Latest CFE News

Get the latest and most important CFE news right to your inbox. I'll keep it to the best stuff and infrequent, promise.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest